Three things stood out: brand, network, and signal.
YC is less about some secret curriculum and more about what it represents. Entering YC signals to the market that you’ve cleared an elite filter. Investors, talent, and customers know you’ve been vetted, and that halo matters. Just look at Parker Conrad—after Zenefits, he could have raised capital anywhere. Yet he still put Rippling through YC. Why? Because the stamp accelerates trust and access in ways money alone can’t.
Then there’s the network. Hundreds of alumni and investors on speed dial. Early customers willing to take a bet because you’re “one of them.” For an early-stage founder, that’s not 7% dilution—it’s jet fuel.
The Blind Spots
But here’s the hard truth: YC isn’t perfect, and the data proved it.
- Most exits are small. The majority of YC outcomes are under $100M. The billion-dollar winners are just 7.7%. The power law is brutal.
- Early hype doesn’t predict success. Companies hot on Demo Day don’t always turn out to be winners. Some of the biggest success stories—like Deel—were overlooked initially.
- Go-to-market is an afterthought. YC is world-class on product and brand, but weaker on GTM. The founders who win don’t just ride YC’s halo; they figure out distribution, sales, and scale on their own—or with outside help.
If you’re a founder, take that last point seriously. Joining YC is a vote of confidence in your product. But world-class products without GTM discipline don’t become category leaders. That’s on you and your team.
The Risk of Scale
YC has expanded aggressively—four cohorts per year, thousands of startups. That creates brand risk. When everyone is “YC-backed,” does the badge still differentiate? The danger is the LinkedIn problem: too many connections, not enough signal.
And yet, the brand endures because the winners endure. A single Stripe or Airbnb can carry the perception of an entire generation of cohorts. Like Andreessen Horowitz, YC has evolved into an asset-gathering machine, deploying billions with predictable LP backing. That’s a smart business model—but one founders need to navigate with clear eyes.
Lessons for Executives
So what does all this mean if you’re an operator, not a founder?
- Understand the power law. If you’re joining a YC-backed company, know that only a small percentage will break out. Make sure you’re betting on the right horse—or that the role accelerates your career regardless of outcome.
- Pressure cuts both ways. YC companies often raise at high valuations early. That creates momentum, but also pressure. Teams that can’t execute with speed and precision burn out fast.
- Don’t outsource GTM thinking. Even if the brand helps with early customers, sustainable growth requires your leadership. Sales, marketing, and RevOps need to professionalize fast—or the YC edge evaporates.
Final Take
Would I advise a young, technical founder to join YC? Absolutely. The experience, network, and brand are worth the 7% equity. But as an executive, I remind myself of something Michael Seibel once told a room full of founders: “You’re not special.”
In the end, YC doesn’t guarantee success. It gives you a louder microphone, a bigger stage, and a faster start. What you do once you’re there—that’s what separates the winners from the rest.
Listen to the Full Episode
Listen to episode 123 on Spotify, Apple, or YouTube, and catch new episodes every Sunday and Thursday.
Want more Topline?
Subscribe to the Topline Newsletter for fresh insights on go-to-market strategy, emerging trends, and real benchmarking data that keeps you ahead of the curve.
